Medicaid Mayhem and its Smallest Casualties

Share
Medicaid Mayhem and its Smallest Casualties

According to Mackenzi Klemann’s article in the Indiana Capital Chronicle, as of October 2026, 58,000 people on HIP in Indiana aren’t in compliance for the new 80-hour work requirement rule (80 hours a month of employment, job training, education at least half-time, volunteering or $580.00 in monthly income) that is set to begin this January.  Or, at least at the time of publication of this article is still set to begin.  If you’re anything like me and looking for any bit of news on this topic, you’ve likely already heard the news that came out last week Friday about President Trump giving states the option to hold off on work requirements until July.  Will Indiana follow suit?  It remains to be seen.  My personal hunch after living in Indiana for 37 years is no, but more concrete information will be sure to come in another article.

Punishment Before the Changes

If having a big glaring headline accusing those on HIP of being noncompliant with work requirements before anyone was even required to log anything isn’t enough of a reason why I feel Indiana will go full steam ahead, consider what’s already been going on.  Even without the new requirements in place, people on HIP are already dealing with gaps in coverage and fighting to get it back for themselves and their families.  According to Casey Smith of The Indiana Capital Chronicle, Indiana’s Medicaid rolls have shrunk by more than 343,000 people in a single year.  This amounts to an 18.5% drop that ranks among the steepest in the country.

There are many reasons for this drop, such as income and household changes, as explained in the linked article above.  But a good chunk of those on HIP who have been dropped are under the umbrella term of being noncompliant, i.e. being eligible for benefits but being dropped due to a missed paper, deadline, income report, and so on, resulting in weeks or even months of missed coverage.  Last week, I mentioned a couple of those people.  This week, it’s past time to address another group of people already falling through the cracks who don’t have the means to fight for themselves; children.

The CHIP(s) are Down

According to a study done by Georgetown University’s Center for Children and Families, there’s been a steep decline in child enrollment in Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program (better known as CHIP) in many areas of the country, but unfortunately, Indiana takes the lead with a 19.8% decline in April 2026 compared to January 2025, which amounts to over 174,000 children being uninsured.  Susan Jo Thomas, executive director of Covering Kids and Families, mentions in another article for the Indiana Capital Chronicle, that mixed status immigrant families are one such reason for this to not reveal their undocumented family members.

“It has the effect of them saying, ‘It’s not worth the risk to the family unit to draw scrutiny or draw attention to our family,’ because on the application you have to list everyone that’s in the household, and it’s scary to reveal that kind of information to a governmental entity,” Thomas said in the article.

And while children aren’t subject to the work requirements that begin in January, they too fall victim to red tape.  Many families with disabled children in Indiana rely not only on Medicaid, but also the Home and Community Based Service Waivers that help fund speech, occupational, physical and behavioral therapies, according to an article written by the WRTV staff.

Ruth Hevelone of Kokomo, a mom of twin boys with autism, is one of many who relies on this waiver and is featured in the above article.  Her son Sammy is able to have 40 hours of therapy a week because of it.  However, on June 1st, FSSA informed Sammy’s family that he was kicked off of Medicaid, impacting his waiver.  Although the family had written FSSA a letter stating their income was waived, they were told months later by FSSA to provide proof of the family’s assets and income.

“You have to turn in everything: your mortgage, 30 days bank statements, 30 days’ pay stubs, everything,” Hevelone said in the article.

The FSSA office was no help either, the article explains.  So, what is the outcome of this story? 

“They said that the paperwork we turned in on May 22 was still sitting on someone’s task list to process, and therefore, because it was never processed it was canceled,” Hevelone explained.

Gone in a SNAP

Another pressing matter concerning Indiana families in the short term are the changes made to the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, also known as SNAP.  Like the Medicaid work requirements, changes to SNAP are also due to President Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill.  However, these changes are happening now instead of in January.  Since taking effect last October, 82,000 fewer Indiana residents are receiving benefits from SNAP, according to Indiana Capital Chronicle’s Mackenzi Klemann.

Much like Medicaid, SNAP has its own work requirements for able-bodied adults aged 18-64 without children.  The good news, if you can call it that, is if you are already meeting requirements for SNAP, you are automatically exempt from Medicaid work requirements.  However, that doesn’t help the other changes made that are mentioned in the above article, like able-bodied adult veterans, homeless people and young adults who have aged out of foster care, people once exempt from work requirements must prove 80 hours of work or lose their benefits.  Able-bodied seniors also have to do these requirements until they’re 64, and when it comes to families with kids, they are only exempt until their youngest is 14, down from age 18.

Failure to meet work, school or volunteer hours for more than three months in a three-year period will result in benefits termination, said Emily Weikert Bryant, executive director of Feeding Indiana’s Hungry, in the article.

I’ve gone on a lot already about work requirements for Medicaid, but having to meet them for SNAP in order for a family or someone without children to be able to afford groceries is just as big of a deal because while one may not need to go to the doctor every day of the week, you do need to eat every day, and it’s just as big of a hurdle to meet as healthcare.

Dr. Shellye Suttles, administrator of the Indianapolis Office of Public Health and Safety's Division of Community Nutrition and Food Policy, said in an article written by Farrah Anderson of WFYI Public Media [that] she's concerned more Hoosiers will struggle to afford groceries as benefits are reduced or lost.

"Neither local government nor charitable food assistance is going to be able to offset the reduction in benefits,” Suttles said.

So… What’s Next?

There’s no sugarcoating the fact that those on HIP, SNAP, or a combination of the two are feeling the literal and figurative pain right now.  Even moving the Medicaid work requirements to July only provides a band-aid.  But in some small way, if Indiana opts into the grace period, it can provide people some time to get things together.  Like always, we will have to wait and see.

Read more